Short answer
They can fill gaps, but they rarely build a business. Many lead services send the same homeowner to more than one contractor, so you race to call first. On Thumbtack you're charged when a matching lead arrives, win or lose. Leads you own, from your site, your Google profile and your own ads, cost more to set up but keep working for you.
Most contractors I talk to have tried at least one of these. Some still use them. Most have mixed feelings.
How do these lead sites charge?
- Thumbtack: you set a price for each lead in your job types. When a matching lead comes in, you're charged that price. You can set a weekly budget.
- Angi and HomeAdvisor: the same company. Pros pay for leads, and the price depends on the job and the area.
- Google Local Services Ads: also pay per lead, but it's Google, your reviews show, and junk leads can be credited back.
What's the catch with shared leads?
If one homeowner filled out one form and three contractors got it, you're racing. The one who calls first, or bids lowest, usually wins. That pushes your price down and your hours up.
Lead quality has been a real problem. In 2023, the FTC finalized an order against HomeAdvisor. The FTC said the company misled service providers about its leads, including whether they matched the jobs and areas the pros asked for. HomeAdvisor had to pay up to $7.2 million.
How do I compare a lead site to my own leads?
Use cost per job, not cost per lead. A cheap lead you never win costs more than a pricey one you do.
- Add up what you paid the lead site over the last three months.
- Count the jobs you won from it in that time.
- Divide the first number by the second. That's your cost per job.
- Do the same math for every other source: your ads, your website, your Google profile.
For a sense of scale, here's what a lead from Google search ads cost in LocaliQ's 2025 data:
| Trade | Cost per lead from search ads |
|---|---|
| General contractors | $165.67 |
| Roofing and gutters | $228.15 |
| Plumbing | $129.02 |
| Heating and furnaces | $129.02 |
| Air conditioning | $127.74 |
National medians from 3,211 campaigns, April 2024 to March 2025. Not Vancouver numbers.
What does owning your leads look like?
- A Google Business Profile that's complete and full of reviews.
- A website with a page for each service, so people find you instead of a lead site.
- Your own ads, sending people to your own landing page.
- Tracking, so you know which source paid off.
These cost more up front. But nobody else gets the same customer, and every review and every page keeps working after you pay for it.
Should a Vancouver contractor advertise in Portland too?
Only if you're licensed there and want the work. Oregon needs a CCB license. Washington needs L&I registration. If you have both, say so on your site and target both sides of the river. If you don't, set your ads and your Google service areas to Washington only, or you'll pay for calls you can't take.
Think about the bridges too. A job in Beaverton may not look far on a map, but it's a long drive at 4 PM. Target the towns you can really get to.
When are lead sites worth it?
- You're new and need jobs while you build your own leads.
- You have a slow month and the cost-per-job math still works.
- You use them for one kind of job and track it closely.
Do this now
- Add up what you paid lead sites in the last three months.
- Count the jobs you won from them, and divide. That's your cost per job.
- Check your Google profile: complete, verified, and 20 or more reviews?
- Make sure your site has a page for each service you want more of.
- Check that your L&I and CCB numbers are on your site.
Want to compare what your leads cost now with what your own could cost? I'll run the numbers with you.
Schedule a callQuestions people ask
Should I quit lead sites right away?
No. Keep them while your own leads build up, and track the cost per job. Cut them when your own leads cost less.
Are Local Services Ads a lead site?
Sort of. They're pay per lead too, but they come from Google, show your reviews, and junk leads can be credited back.