Schedule a call

AI and websites · 4 min read · Nov 15, 2026

Why every contractor website in town looks the same now

Same fonts, same buttons, same town pages. Here's why so many local sites blur together, what Google actually says about AI content, and how I build differently.

Short answer

A lot of them are built the same way now: an AI tool, a template and an afternoon. Same fonts, same rounded buttons, a page for every town. Google doesn't punish a site only for using AI. It does push down pages made to game search instead of help people. And customers can tell.

Look up contractors around Vancouver and Portland and click through a few sites. By the third one, they start to blur together. It almost feels like every other one is the same AI-built template. That's not an accident.

What do these sites have in common?

  • Same fonts, same layout, same pill-shaped buttons.
  • Either a one-page brochure, or dozens of AI-written pages.
  • A page for every town, each over 3,000 characters, saying the same thing with the name swapped.
  • Broken links. Social buttons that go to someone else's page.
  • Nothing about who the business is, how they work, or why you'd pick them.

Why is this happening now?

AI tools made it fast and cheap to make a website. That part is fine. I use AI too. The problem is when the tool does the whole job and nobody checks it. A site that took an afternoon looks like it took an afternoon.

I've talked with two local businesses this year who got exactly this. One had a site from another agency in the area: broken in places, hard to contact through, and more town pages than real content. The other builds homes and pole barns and does remodels. Same problems, plus links that sent people to the wrong social platform.

Does Google penalize AI-written content?

Not for being AI-written. Google has said it cares about whether content helps people, not how it was made. What it does go after is content made mainly to rank, cranked out in bulk, with little value. Its spam rules call that scaled content abuse.

So a page for every town, all saying the same thing, is a risk no matter who wrote it. Google calls those doorway pages.

Google also suggests asking three things about any page. Who made it? How was it made? Why was it made? If the honest answer to "why" is "to rank," that's a problem.

Why does it matter if a site feels generic?

Because your website is your brand online. When it doesn't feel made by a person, it feels like nobody cared. That isn't honest to the business, and it lowers trust. Customers might not say it, but they feel it.

A good site does three things a generic one can't. It shows who you are. It shows what you do, with real photos of real work. And it tells people why they should pick you.

How do I build a site differently?

This is the process I use for clients and for my own site:

  1. Research. I look at your business, your area and your competitors. What are they doing right? What are they missing?
  2. Plan the pages. I work out which pages will help you show up and help customers decide. Usually 10 to 20, depending on how many services you have.
  3. Build the brand into it. Clean, and built around how your business looks and talks.
  4. Write for real questions. Pages and guides that answer what people in your area search for, set up for Google and for AI search.
  5. Test everything. Every link and every button, on a phone and a computer.

I use AI as a tool along the way, and I say so. I check everything it makes. The research, the decisions and the final call on every page are mine.

I did this for Natrix Precast, the precast concrete company where I run the marketing. The site went from one page to a full site with guides. In the 28 days after launch it had 3,323 search impressions and 79 clicks. The 28 days before: 329 and 12.

My work is a reflection of me. I want every site I build to be something the owner is proud to show customers, and something I'm proud to put my name on.

Do this now

  1. Put your site next to two competitors' sites. Could you swap the logos and not notice?
  2. Count your town pages. If they all say the same thing, they may be hurting you.
  3. Check that the photos on your site are of your real work.
  4. Read your homepage out loud. Does it sound like you?
  5. Tap every link and button on your phone.

Want a site that looks and sounds like your business? Let's talk about it.

Schedule a call

Questions people ask

Is it bad to use AI to write my website?

Not by itself. It's bad when nobody checks it, when it says nothing specific about your business, or when it's used to crank out pages to game search. Use it as a helper, then make it yours.

Should I have a page for every city I serve?

Only for places where you do a lot of work and have something real to say: jobs you did there, local rules, what people there ask. A few strong area pages beat dozens of copies.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, guidance about AI-generated content, Feb 2023
  2. Google Search Central, creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
  3. Google Search Central, spam policies: doorway pages and scaled content abuse
AJ Miranda

One person in Vancouver, WA. I build the sites, run the search and manage the ads I write about. About me · Work with me

Want this done for your business?

Tell me where you're at. We'll figure out if I'm the right fit.

Schedule a call